Modified:
08 Mar 2010
by Ananya
Vote totals:
Yes:
53%
No:
41%
Neutral:
6%
Subscribe to This Debate
You are not currently subscribed to this debate.
Misc Debates
Subscribe to Newsletter
Tell a Friend
(Use commas to separate)
DEBATE: SPACE EXPLORATION IS A WASTE OF MONEY
Posted by: jerichokb
Karma:
110
Billions of dollars are spent every year by the world's space agencies, but does this money bring us any benefit, or should we pull the plug and spend it elsewhere?
Executive Summary
Join The Debate
All the Yes points
All the No points
SPACE EXPLORATION IS A WASTE OF MONEY
against space exploration
Science may well give us good things. We all know velcro came from NASA. But why bother spending all this money exploring space and finding out there was water on Mars at some point in the last few thousand years (we have water in Earth) when these same great minds could be applied to finding better ways to power humanity's insatiable desire for energy, to feeding the starving millions around the globe, and generally making life down here better before looking up into the heavens.The needs of humanity should always come first. While there are people on Earth who need help, they should be helped, rather than seeing money spent on sending robots onto other planets.Also why take so much time and money to learn about Mars or any other planet, when we know so little about our own? We should learn more about Earth and the ocean before wasting time and money on Space exploration.
Space Exploration epitimizes the spirit of humanities insatiable appetite to explore that which is beyond our reach. Explortion of the unknown has lead to new civilaztions, new ways of life, and world unity. We cannot help but to explore new worlds regardless of how far away they are. Now , the reason why money is not wasted in the space program is becuase all the development that comes out of NASA leads to a direct benefit in our everyday lives. It is only becuase they have become so profficient at what they do, most of the public has written off what they do and standard procedures unworthy much media coverage until something goes wrong. But everyday we use products that were develped for space programs, such at CAT scan machines, hi-res digital photography, mylar survuval blankets, GPS, computer networking , internet access, ect. The list can go on and on. NASA spends the time and money to develope these products for use in space, but usually there are many civilian applications for the same products. Production of these product leads to redevelpoment, sales and distribution - all of whihc leads to more jobs, becuase somebody has to build them, and sell them , and fix them , and repair them. One last point, we know that russia and china have both put men in space and now even more countries are getting involved. Obviously we have seen the power of Google map ( and that is only at the civilian level) Imagine now, that other powerful countries have satelites to spy on us and can position weapons directly above our country , dont you think it would be a good idea to be abloe to stave that off. If we decided to stop "wasting" money on space programs, we can say goodbye to many new developments that will be out of reach of garage scientist and we can expect to be overwhelmed with visitors in the skies above the US. As far as starving children are concerned - americas poor people have xboxes and cell phones - starving countries are that way becuase their governements are stealing the millions of dollars of relief that we are already sending them. Just remeber this , without exploration into theunknown, America would not be here today -- without exploration of space, America will not be here tomorrow
What do you think? Vote on this point below.
SPACE EXPLORATION IS A WASTE OF MONEY
Space exploration gives us no direct benefit
There have been no direct benefits from space travel; the only 'good things' to come from it are indirect, and not the end aims. NASA weren't aiming for velcro, but the moon. We got velcro, the moon gave us nothing except some pretty pictures of the planet below. Scientists and inventors could give us the same by-products for a lot less cost if the associated space exploration was removed from the equation.All the by-products of the space race could have been developed by commercial companies aiming to make a profit by developing good products and selling them, at a fraction of the cost: the Post-it note is possibly as useful as velcro, but was developed by 3M at a fraction of the cost.Furthermore, a lot of the 'advances' space exploration bring us is irrelevant to daily life: why bother spending money developing a pen that works in zero-gravity when a) a pencil will do and b) the vast majority of the world's 6 billion people will never experience zero gravity?
However indirect they might be, the advances would not have come were it not for the space programmes of NASA, as there would have been no technological need. Space exploration gave impetus to projects that have been useful, as well as providing valuable scientific knowledge. For example, the laser-targetting of mirrors left on the moon by Apollo astronauts helps test and understand basic physics, which in turn leads to advances in very earthly things like electronics, hyper-conductivity, etc.
What do you think? Vote on this point below.
SPACE EXPLORATION IS A WASTE OF MONEY
The Earth itself is not fully explored yet
Space exploration has always been a gimmick. The USA was doing it only to look better than the USSR and vice versa; it has never really been about the science.
There are far more valuable scientific endeavours to fund, such as the exploration of our own planet. The seabed, especially around volcanic regions, is relatively unexplored, as is Antarctica. One recent news story about a ‘lost tribe’ also highlighted the fact that we are not in contact with all indigenous peoples across the planet.
The scientific knowledge obtainable from our own planet, particularly organisms that inhabit locations with extreme conditions, offers far more value than that of space.
Potential organisms to be found in space (such as on Mars) offer exactly the same value to the scientific community, and perhaps more, as the conditions would be far more extreme than those found on the Earth.
What do you think? Vote on this point below.
SPACE EXPLORATION IS A WASTE OF MONEY
A commercial space industry is taking over
Even if space exploration was a good target of funding in the past, it is now a growing target of venture capital and private ingenuity. For example, SpaceX's reusable rocket that is expected to reduce launch costs for commercial satelites, Bigelow Aerospace's investment in space tourism, and Virgin Galactic's expected space-faring plane, among others. Now that private companies are intending to supply space access on the cheap, it is useless to spend all that money on expensive platforms such as the space shuttle.
the corporations will move in whenever they see opportunity for solid profit, but it is always science, and often government funded research, that finds those opportunities in the first place.for example you mention satellites which are an integral part of the global communications industry, which in itself would not exist without first having the invention of telephone wires, radio waves, etc., all which have led up to space satellites.as for the prospects of space tourism again that is simply a result of the fact that governments have funded space research for all these years and finally it is getting to a point where it's cheap enough and safe enough to send paying citizens up there.corporations will not do anything that doesn't guarantee profit so will they investigate whether there is water on the moon? whether it is possible in the future to colonize it? no. it's too much of a risk so the government has to pay for it.
What do you think? Vote on this point below.
SPACE EXPLORATION IS A WASTE OF MONEY
the new crisis on planet earth: finish your priorities before starting new ones
there are two major crisis going on at your home planet. global warming and the world wild economic crisis, both are severe. if the government doesnt handle the economic crisis with care we all will end up poor. how can we feed the poor,fend for our selves and take care of really expensive space travels?space travel is a unwanted business for now. how many of you'll know that nasa lost count of there budget after the first billlions of dollar after the first year? is this more iportant than caring for the needy? when so mny people are dieng as we speak can we just neglect them and say "the money we just spend went for a good cause, and these few hundreds of people who died are nothing because if we dont find a nother planet to escape the clutures of global warming we all will die" is that fair for them?i say no and what will you say? Global warming is the second most severe issue the earth is going through. we have to take care of our planet before we go roaming other planets. if the great legendary tribes of yesterday were here to see all this they would not belive that long time ago there used to be pure air to breath e and man and animal lived side by side.now everything is destroyed. if we take care of this problem with with care we would be able to overcome this disaster.
SPACE EXPLORATION IS A WASTE OF MONEY
Scientific knowledge has value beyond the measurements of cost
The argument that humanity will need to find a new habitat to survive is a stretch and paranoid. Humans are already dying due to poverty and the lack of food etc. The millions of dollars of government funding that goes to space exploration could instead be used to save the humans who are already dying in our world. No-one is going to argue against the value of knowledge but there is a greater value in spending more on food supplies which has a certain result of feeding the hungry, whereas certain results are not present in the theory of discovering a sustainable planet.
Knowledge is invaluable. Furthering our understanding of how the universe came into being, and ultimately how we came into being, cannot be measured as useful solely in terms of cost. What price to pay for knowing that in the future, humanity can be saved because there are other planets out there capable of sustaining life?
Scientific knowledge has intrinsic worth. Space exploration is just one aspect of science that seems to have little impact on our daily lives. Who cares if the Higgs-Boson exists? Very few people. But governments have funded a new particle collider at CERN to find it because they recognise the importance of finding it to understanding the universe.
What do you think? Vote on this point below.
SPACE EXPLORATION IS A WASTE OF MONEY
The cost isn't actually very high
Although the cost is not high relative to other government expenditure, it is still an additional cost that the taxpayer is burdened with. If this debate is saying that space exploration is pointless then it means spending money on nothing so is definitely a waste. Even if it's a small amount it is still an amount that could be spent elsewhere.Everyday in Delhi B.P.S buses are are getting blasted due to the default in the engeenering.So we shouldspend money on it not for the space exploration.We should spend money on the coton bags and jute bags.We should spend money on Afforestation .We live on the earth so I request everyone to spend money on the Earth not on space
Compared to other areas of government spending (e.g. military), the cost of space exploration simply isn't ridiculously high. There have been space vehicles built in the private sector for as little as $25m, a drop in the ocean compared to US spending in Iraq, and the net benefits outweigh even these figures.
What do you think? Vote on this point below.
SPACE EXPLORATION IS A WASTE OF MONEY
It is in man's nature to explore his environment.
Indeed it is our nature to explore our environment - but that environment is not zero-gravity, extremes (and not the bearable extremes we experience on earth) of temperatures and terrain.Indeed, there is still a substantial area of our own planet we have yet to fully explore. Why rush off to space when we've not seen all of our own planet yet?
Without the urge to ‘see what’s out there’ the continents would still be populated by the indigenous races. North Americans would all be Native Americans, Africans would all be black, and Australia would have only Aborigines and kangaroos.
Let’s take this argument to its extremities: Suppose no one had ever wondered if there was another little village somewhere in the world. Then every group of civilised people would have to grow in their own shell of ignorance. The printing press would have remained in Germany unless some other nation happened to stumble on the same process. The same would apply to…well, the list is just too long and life is too short.
What do you think? Vote on this point below.
SPACE EXPLORATION IS A WASTE OF MONEY
Many discoveries have been made as a result of Space Exploration
Although these discoveries have been made, do you really think that velcro and non-stick pans are more important than feeding the starving, solving the current economic crisis or dealing with the environmental issues? Though these inventions may be useful, we can survive without them. A normal pan still cooks your meals, buttons and zips can do up your jumpers or clothes. These items are simply a luxury we cannot afford and we do not need them. The thousands of starving people cannot survive without food so why spend money on products which we do not need.
Many discoveries and products have been developed from the knowledge gained from space exploration. For example, NASA created Velcro which is now used in many clothing items, bags and so forth. Non-stick pans and surfaces were also created as a result of space exploration. Now we can cook without worrying whether or not our cakes will stick to the sides of our pans. Overall, space exploration has provided us with new knowledge and as a result of this, many new and intriguing inventions have been made.
What do you think? Vote on this point below.
SPACE EXPLORATION IS A WASTE OF MONEY
Space
space is obviously not meant for humans to cross. Much more so than even in the oceans it is an environment that is inhospitable to humans. We cant survive in space itself. The vast majority of planets are either too hot or too cold for human habitation and many are gas giants or have atmospheres that we could not breath. It would take many times longer than the lifespan of a human to cross the vast gulf between the stars and even if we could do this through a deep sleep then when they wake up those who were sent would be way out on their own, with no prospect of help and within a tiny community.
SPACE EXPLORATION IS A WASTE OF MONEY
Its not a waste
Space travel has given us a lot of new things for example the micro chip, the CAT scan and so on. You might say that we could just put together a group of scientist to figure it out, but and idea has to come from something, and they wouldn't just make a CAT scan if someone told to to make something to scan a brain, and even if they would, it would take a lot more time. Also, space travel could benefit our future, if we ended up making settlements on the moon or mars, we might be able to mine there and get rare minerals, or a huge supply of a mineral, boosting economy. Think of America, if someone had put a stop to earth's exploration due to poverty, we wouldn't have one economically strong country(USA) to help the poor.
SPACE EXPLORATION IS A WASTE OF MONEY
Read those and tell me space exploration is a waste of time and money. It may have taken peoples lives, but it has given back more lives then taken. We may not get any short term benefits, but the long term ones could be better than any other short term benefits out there. It may take a lot of money, but I think i rather spend my taxes on space exploration then welfare families. Don't say we have no direct benefits form it because we do. If we didn't have it you, me, or any other person probably wouldn't be posting information on this website right now. So keep saying stuff like that, but I rather let the perfessionals do what they need to do for anything.
SPACE EXPLORATION IS A WASTE OF MONEY
Plastics Industry/Internet
Plastic were invented by material engineers working on the space program. it is a large, profitable, and useful industry. Parts of your computer are made of it. Innovations in computing were needed. More efficient fuels were researched. The Internet was a joint military and NASA project. Obviously you are taking advantage of them right now.
Vote on the overall debate: Space exploration is a waste of money
What do you think? Vote on this debate below.

dhc
|21:45, 31 March 08
|Karma Score: 1367
|Applause: 1
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
dhc
|21:45, 31 March 08
|Karma Score: 1367
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
ESRA
|12:56, 21 October 09
|Karma Score: 0
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
ALPER
|13:04, 21 October 09
|Karma Score: 0
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
112ygt
|13:24, 21 October 09
|Karma Score: 0
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
dhc
|12:24, 01 April 08
|Karma Score: 1367
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
dhc
|12:24, 01 April 08
|Karma Score: 1367
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
aporch
|12:59, 21 October 09
|Karma Score: 3
|Applause: 1
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
ALPER
|13:10, 21 October 09
|Karma Score: 0
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
berkay
|13:11, 21 October 09
|Karma Score: 0
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
m.akif17
|13:28, 21 October 09
|Karma Score: 0
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
m.akif17
|13:28, 21 October 09
|Karma Score: 0
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
dhc
|14:15, 08 June 08
|Karma Score: 1367
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
dhc
|14:15, 08 June 08
|Karma Score: 1367
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
yosef
|07:14, 30 July 09
|Karma Score: 201
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
yxmyxm
|22:41, 18 January 10
|Karma Score: 94
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
hafsa_j
|14:33, 25 February 10
|Karma Score: 3
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
dhc
|19:07, 01 April 08
|Karma Score: 1367
|Applause: 1
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
dhc
|19:07, 01 April 08
|Karma Score: 1367
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
dhc
|19:09, 01 April 08
|Karma Score: 1367
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
dhc
|19:09, 01 April 08
|Karma Score: 1367
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
yosef
|07:06, 30 July 09
|Karma Score: 201
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
dhc
|05:47, 19 May 08
|Karma Score: 1367
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
dhc
|05:47, 19 May 08
|Karma Score: 1367
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
admin
|19:25, 23 May 09
|Karma Score: 14
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
admin
|19:25, 23 May 09
|Karma Score: 14
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
jzk
|05:18, 18 June 09
|Karma Score: 3
|Applause: 1
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
jzk
|05:20, 18 June 09
|Karma Score: 3
|Applause: 1
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
eregon888
|12:23, 01 October 09
|Karma Score: 14
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
Rory123
|00:59, 14 December 09
|Karma Score: 3
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
lailawise
|20:14, 08 March 10
|Karma Score: 3
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply