Modified:
28 Nov 2009
by Admin

Vote totals:

Yes:

33%

No:

67%

Neutral:

0%

 
Subscribe to This Debate
You are not currently subscribed to this debate.


Subscribe to Newsletter
Tell a Friend
(Use commas to separate)
Bookmark and Share


DEBATE: SPOTIFY WILL END THE ERA OF ILLEGAL MUSIC DOWNLOADING

As the new free music on demand program, Spotify, gains momentum amongst music lovers everywhere including the support of U2 whom released their new album with spotify free to all, a week before general release, can Spotify capitalise on the slow demise of Pirate bay and help stop illegal music downloading altogether?





SPOTIFY WILL END THE ERA OF ILLEGAL MUSIC DOWNLOADING


Free on demand music


Free music promising high quality with a simple user interface similar to itune and saved play list on the program. Spotify is offering the public a legal, safe and simple way to enjoy free music.

The quality of the music is so much better then the other alternatives, especially you tube, more choice is available. The interface works better then most of the competition.

Relying on the internet could be seen as a down side but with it existing in nearly every home and also the mass growth of wifi and other mobile internet options this seem like a redundant negative. As for being able to play it on your mp3 player.... well if you like the music enough to want to own it then perhaps buying it for a small fee off of places like itunes and amazon should be considered its an excelent place to see if you like something this could improve the quality of successful bands and also champion music which would normally not get a look in. Its an awsome place to be able to listen to the music of a band you about to see live with out having to spend any more cash.

Also the more exciting element of Spotify being used as a DJ application, no more "have you got this tune mate?" dj: "Oh I don't have that one sorry" I know people are going to say that it will be tough using as a DJ tool considering you need the net but like I said before mobile connection is becoming more and more affordable and usable.

This is more attractive to artists and record labels. Spotify should include a rent option for connection with ipods and mp3 players in order to generate funds for artists this will help reduce a lot of illegal problems.

Free on demand music already exists on youtube and as a application on myspace and bebo. Further, on google playlist, users can already save their youtube favorites post registration. None of them seem to have prevented illegal downloading. The reason why people download or buy music be it legal or illegal is so that they can have access to it anywhere on their mp3 players. Spotify requires the user to be next to a computer and have access to the internet before the streaming begins.


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Yes
Strongly Yes
Mostly Yes
Partially Yes
Neutral
Partially No
Mostly No
Strongly No
Absolutely No

SPOTIFY WILL END THE ERA OF ILLEGAL MUSIC DOWNLOADING


Quality without the hassle of long searches


Although it isn't a new concept, Spotify is in collaboration with the four major record labels and independent digital music distributors which distinguishes it from similar services like google jukebox and napster, as it offers a specific result at a high playing quality.



SPOTIFY WILL END THE ERA OF ILLEGAL MUSIC DOWNLOADING


Frees up your hard drive


Having a 'cloud' access to your private collection of music will release your computer hard drive memory. In addition it allows a more remote access to your collection on any computer you go to, as long as it has the spotify program. Picture the process you go through when you get a new laptop, there is no longer a need to spend time transferring your torrent of music across. Done!



SPOTIFY WILL END THE ERA OF ILLEGAL MUSIC DOWNLOADING


Spotify does not permit downloads


Whilst users can gain access to a vast catalogue of music when they are sitting in front on their computers, there is no way of taking it with them when they leave the house. For this they will need a way to export music to their Ipods/Mp3 players - with illegal downloading sure to remain a popular choice for many.



SPOTIFY WILL END THE ERA OF ILLEGAL MUSIC DOWNLOADING


Works without internet with a monthly fee, and allows downloads for iTunes style one-track purchases


Well, it's true - the adverts every twenty minutes make clear as much.



SPOTIFY WILL END THE ERA OF ILLEGAL MUSIC DOWNLOADING


Does not work without the internet


Illegal downloads carries a risk of poor quality, legal action and viruses. Spotify eliminates that risk altogether. The lack of portability is a problem being fixed as news of a iphone app allowing temporary saved playlists for users.

As web based program, it relies on streaming rather than downloading. People will inevitably want to have the actual file of the tract to access to whenever they wish, and since we are not yet able to access wireless internet where ever we are, illegal downloading will still exist.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/technology/2009/02/will_spotify_change_the_music.html


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Yes
Strongly Yes
Mostly Yes
Partially Yes
Neutral
Partially No
Mostly No
Strongly No
Absolutely No

SPOTIFY WILL END THE ERA OF ILLEGAL MUSIC DOWNLOADING


The advertisement every twenty minutes will ruin the enjoyment of music


Most tracks don't last 20 minutes, so you aren't interrupting the middle of a track, and if they happen regularly you can plan your playlist around them. It is impossible to say that music won't be interrupted anyway - for instance, your mp3 player might run out of batteries - and if the adverts are relevant to your needs, you might want to hear them.

Its all well and good being free, but at what cost? Listeners will be subjected to a thirty second advert spot every twenty minutes. We download music so that we won't be interrupted by outside influences beyond our control. There is a reason why BBC radio stations remain popular amongst the public.


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Yes
Strongly Yes
Mostly Yes
Partially Yes
Neutral
Partially No
Mostly No
Strongly No
Absolutely No

SPOTIFY WILL END THE ERA OF ILLEGAL MUSIC DOWNLOADING


Tracks people want can't always be obtained on spotify, or even at all legally.


For example, a theme from a game of which no soundtrack CD has been made.

People will search a wide variety of sites to find an obscure track and if they can't find it legally, they will look on illegal sites.




Vote on the overall debate: Spotify WILL end the era of illegal music downloading

What do you think?  Vote on this debate below.
Absolutely Yes
Strongly Yes
Mostly Yes
Partially Yes
Neutral
Partially No
Mostly No
Strongly No
Absolutely No
1. Free on demand music
# 1

Free music promising high quality with a simple user interface similar to itune and saved play list on the program. Spotify is offering the public a legal, safe and simple way to enjoy free music.

The quality of the music is so much better then the other alternatives, especially you tube, more choice is available. The interface works better then most of the competition.

Relying on the internet could be seen as a down side but with it existing in nearly every home and also the mass growth of wifi and other mobile internet options this seem like a redundant negative. As for being able to play it on your mp3 player.... well if you like the music enough to want to own it then perhaps buying it for a small fee off of places like itunes and amazon should be considered its an excelent place to see if you like something this could improve the quality of successful bands and also champion music which would normally not get a look in. Its an awsome place to be able to listen to the music of a band you about to see live with out having to spend any more cash.

Also the more exciting element of Spotify being used as a DJ application, no more "have you got this tune mate?" dj: "Oh I don't have that one sorry" I know people are going to say that it will be tough using as a DJ tool considering you need the net but like I said before mobile connection is becoming more and more affordable and usable.

This is more attractive to artists and record labels. Spotify should include a rent option for connection with ipods and mp3 players in order to generate funds for artists this will help reduce a lot of illegal problems.

admin

|

07:59, 27 February 09

|

Karma Score: 14


# 2

Free on demand music already exists on youtube and as a application on myspace and bebo. Further, on google playlist, users can already save their youtube favorites post registration. None of them seem to have prevented illegal downloading. The reason why people download or buy music be it legal or illegal is so that they can have access to it anywhere on their mp3 players. Spotify requires the user to be next to a computer and have access to the internet before the streaming begins.

admin

|

07:59, 27 February 09

|

Karma Score: 14



2. Quality without the hassle of long searches
# 1

Although it isn't a new concept, Spotify is in collaboration with the four major record labels and independent digital music distributors which distinguishes it from similar services like google jukebox and napster, as it offers a specific result at a high playing quality.

admin

|

08:13, 27 February 09

|

Karma Score: 14



3. Frees up your hard drive
# 1

Having a 'cloud' access to your private collection of music will release your computer hard drive memory. In addition it allows a more remote access to your collection on any computer you go to, as long as it has the spotify program. Picture the process you go through when you get a new laptop, there is no longer a need to spend time transferring your torrent of music across. Done!

admin

|

09:02, 27 February 09

|

Karma Score: 14



4. Spotify does not permit downloads
# 1

Whilst users can gain access to a vast catalogue of music when they are sitting in front on their computers, there is no way of taking it with them when they leave the house. For this they will need a way to export music to their Ipods/Mp3 players - with illegal downloading sure to remain a popular choice for many.

admin

|

08:46, 28 February 09

|

Karma Score: 14



5. Works without internet with a monthly fee, and allows downloads for iTunes style one-track purchases
# 1

Well, it's true - the adverts every twenty minutes make clear as much.

Fensfield

|

15:26, 28 November 09

|

Karma Score: 3



1. Does not work without the internet
# 1

As web based program, it relies on streaming rather than downloading. People will inevitably want to have the actual file of the tract to access to whenever they wish, and since we are not yet able to access wireless internet where ever we are, illegal downloading will still exist.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/technology/2009/02/will_spotify_change_the_music.html

admin

|

08:04, 27 February 09

|

Karma Score: 14


# 2

Illegal downloads carries a risk of poor quality, legal action and viruses. Spotify eliminates that risk altogether. The lack of portability is a problem being fixed as news of a iphone app allowing temporary saved playlists for users.

admin

|

08:04, 27 February 09

|

Karma Score: 14



2. The advertisement every twenty minutes will ruin the enjoyment of music
# 1

Its all well and good being free, but at what cost? Listeners will be subjected to a thirty second advert spot every twenty minutes. We download music so that we won't be interrupted by outside influences beyond our control. There is a reason why BBC radio stations remain popular amongst the public.

admin

|

08:38, 27 February 09

|

Karma Score: 14


# 2

Most tracks don't last 20 minutes, so you aren't interrupting the middle of a track, and if they happen regularly you can plan your playlist around them. It is impossible to say that music won't be interrupted anyway - for instance, your mp3 player might run out of batteries - and if the adverts are relevant to your needs, you might want to hear them.

admin

|

08:38, 27 February 09

|

Karma Score: 14



3. Tracks people want can't always be obtained on spotify, or even at all legally.
# 1

For example, a theme from a game of which no soundtrack CD has been made.

People will search a wide variety of sites to find an obscure track and if they can't find it legally, they will look on illegal sites.

admin

|

11:02, 06 March 09

|

Karma Score: 14



Loading...