Modified:
07 Nov 2009
by Admin

Vote totals:

Yes:

100%

No:

0%

Neutral:

0%

 
Subscribe to This Debate
You are not currently subscribed to this debate.


Subscribe to Newsletter
Tell a Friend
(Use commas to separate)
Bookmark and Share


DEBATE: SHOULD THE BAN ON THE PLAYGROUND GAME 'BRITISH BULLDOG' BE OVERTURNED IN AN ATTEMPT TO COMBAT CHILDHOOD OBESITY?

British Bulldog is a traditional playground game a bit like tag; players have to run from one side of the playing field to the other without being caught by one of the designated 'bulldogs'. It can get quite violent, which has led to it being banned by many schools. But is this cotton wool approach damaging our children? Considering the growing problem of childhood obesity, this debate considers whether we should in fact be encouraging the return of physically demanding games to the playground.





SHOULD THE BAN ON THE PLAYGROUND GAME 'BRITISH BULLDOG' BE OVERTURNED IN AN ATTEMPT TO COMBAT CHILDHOOD OBESITY?


Heart disease kills more people than minor cuts and grazes


In a day and age where Britain is getting fatter and the obesity rate is raising to one in four children, something needs to be done. Yes, parents may feel that their child will be at danger by playing games such as British Bulldog and tag, but they will be in danger of minor cuts and bruises, not life threatening conditions such as heart disease and type 2 diabetes. Surely a simple assessment of the two risks reveals what the answer to this question is; lift the ban on British Bulldog.

Exercise is important for health, but it can be gained by playing other, less violent games than British Bulldog. Football or skipping are non-contact activities that also provide plenty of aerobic exercise without running the risk of broken bones.


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Yes
Strongly Yes
Mostly Yes
Partially Yes
Neutral
Partially No
Mostly No
Strongly No
Absolutely No

SHOULD THE BAN ON THE PLAYGROUND GAME 'BRITISH BULLDOG' BE OVERTURNED IN AN ATTEMPT TO COMBAT CHILDHOOD OBESITY?


There are many health benefits to be gained by parents removing the cotton wool from around their children


Children are meant to be boisterous, they are meant to get dirty and get bruised. In fact, childhood is when people mature their immune system. A child should be exposed to natural dirt so their bodies are equipped to deal with such germs in adult life. So by removing the cotton wool, not only will children’s immune systems gain strength but they will also lose weight and be less likely to suffer from illnesses associated with lack of exercise such as high blood pressure. If we lifted the ban on British Bulldog, perhaps parents would see how their cotton wool is suffocating their child’s health.



SHOULD THE BAN ON THE PLAYGROUND GAME 'BRITISH BULLDOG' BE OVERTURNED IN AN ATTEMPT TO COMBAT CHILDHOOD OBESITY?


There are many social benefits too!


Childhood games such as British Bulldog gave children an opportunity to interact with each other. In a day and age where technology is so advanced it is taking over human interaction, such games are needed so children learn how to behave around other children. If we were to ban all contact games in school playgrounds the only things children would play with at lunch time is personal stereos and handheld games. Children would have no awareness of how they should behave around other children. This lack of social awareness would then be transferred to adult life, making Britain a very isolated place.

British Bulldog is not a focus on violence, but even if someone gets a few cuts and bruises, it will teach them not to be a wimp.

Games based on violence, like British Bulldog, surely only teach children that the way to get ahead is to use brute force and shove anyone weaker than you out of the way. Unlike team sports, like football or even games like 'Stuck in the mud' where children have to work together, British Bulldog doesn't teach children about team work.


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Yes
Strongly Yes
Mostly Yes
Partially Yes
Neutral
Partially No
Mostly No
Strongly No
Absolutely No

SHOULD THE BAN ON THE PLAYGROUND GAME 'BRITISH BULLDOG' BE OVERTURNED IN AN ATTEMPT TO COMBAT CHILDHOOD OBESITY?


Too little exercise


It's not as if those giving chase are armed. All physical activities should be encouraged, including dancing. What concerns me is the level to which parents bringing their children to school by car is tolerated. Schools should get together with their local Traffic & Transport dept. and ban parking within a half mile radius of each school and children being given lifts (unless they are injured) should be expelled. Children old enough to go to school are old enough to walk there.



SHOULD THE BAN ON THE PLAYGROUND GAME 'BRITISH BULLDOG' BE OVERTURNED IN AN ATTEMPT TO COMBAT CHILDHOOD OBESITY?


Let the children play!


Children are supposed to play when they are young - it helps them develop. Despite popular belief, British Buldog it's a game that teaches you how to deal with agressivity. There are nice people in the world and "not so nice" people. If you don't learn since you're a child to stand up for yourself, than you will never learn. And plus - it is also a game of strategy - ho to catch first, in order to make things easyer.



SHOULD THE BAN ON THE PLAYGROUND GAME 'BRITISH BULLDOG' BE OVERTURNED IN AN ATTEMPT TO COMBAT CHILDHOOD OBESITY?


Make it safer!


Of course there are minor bruisers - than make the playground safer. It is easier than to make an invesment from the local autorities to just ban the game. But lets have a better look: all major sports - have accidents : football, baschetball, Boeing, karate and people are still doing it - and let me say: very fit people, who do not suffer of obesity. Thus, in order to help children become fit adults, and in order to keep tradition, British Buldog should not be banned!



SHOULD THE BAN ON THE PLAYGROUND GAME 'BRITISH BULLDOG' BE OVERTURNED IN AN ATTEMPT TO COMBAT CHILDHOOD OBESITY?


Playground sports will only be detrimental to obese children’s self esteem


Yes, children can be cruel, but unfortunately discrimination is part of life. You can't ban any competitive situations just because some people will have to lose; that is no preparation for the real world.

Picking teams is always a traumatic time for the chubby kid; being the last fatty standing. Children are cruel and they may even insist that the obese children are not allowed to play on their team. Such a public rejection by their peers is deeply embarrassing and degrading. Not only will the obese child not play the game on such an occasion, but they would go home with a low self esteem and may comfort eat. Obese children may even comfort eat after a poor performance in one such game at school. Once obese, children need special attention with regard to exercise, not just shoved into the deep pool.


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Yes
Strongly Yes
Mostly Yes
Partially Yes
Neutral
Partially No
Mostly No
Strongly No
Absolutely No

SHOULD THE BAN ON THE PLAYGROUND GAME 'BRITISH BULLDOG' BE OVERTURNED IN AN ATTEMPT TO COMBAT CHILDHOOD OBESITY?


compensation culture makes playground sports impossible


Britain is following America with regard to, among other things, their compensation culture. Places of work are being sued; professionals are being sued and public enterprises such as schools and hospitals are also being sued. If rough and tumble games are played at school, and a child gets hurt, a school could be left in the red after paying out a fortune in compensation. In a growing technological market, education is increasingly important and so educational institutions need to take all the precautions they can to keep open.



SHOULD THE BAN ON THE PLAYGROUND GAME 'BRITISH BULLDOG' BE OVERTURNED IN AN ATTEMPT TO COMBAT CHILDHOOD OBESITY?


the answer to obesity lays outside the school’s reach


As with anything, the buck for obesity is trying to be pushed elsewhere. Now we are hearing the banning of violent games from school playgrounds is to blame! However, boys were the main players of such games whilst girls sat around crayoning and plaiting hair. But girls were no more obese than boys back when obesity was described as an epidemic. So this shows that the banning of British Bulldog in playgrounds was not the cause of obesity and so lifting the ban will not be the solution to obesity.



SHOULD THE BAN ON THE PLAYGROUND GAME 'BRITISH BULLDOG' BE OVERTURNED IN AN ATTEMPT TO COMBAT CHILDHOOD OBESITY?


Lifestyle changes are needed, not child’s play


Merely lifting the ban on violent games such as British Bulldog will make no difference to our obesity epidemic. For a start, it is only helping children; obese parents need to be helped. If a child witnesses their parent slobbing on the sofa constantly when at school they will exhibit the same behaviour, regardless of whether contact games are allowed in the playground.

The energy that would be used by exercising in lunch time may not be enough for binging Britain. If the parents remained uneducated about food, and packing a stodgy pack lunch for their obese child, a game of British Bulldog may not even burn off the calories of the lunch, let alone their breakfast and tea.

Unfortunately there are no quick solutions to obesity, we need a British reformation.




Vote on the overall debate: Should the ban on the playground game 'British Bulldog' be overturned in an attempt to combat childhood obesity?

What do you think?  Vote on this debate below.
Absolutely Yes
Strongly Yes
Mostly Yes
Partially Yes
Neutral
Partially No
Mostly No
Strongly No
Absolutely No
1. Heart disease kills more people than minor cuts and grazes
# 1

In a day and age where Britain is getting fatter and the obesity rate is raising to one in four children, something needs to be done. Yes, parents may feel that their child will be at danger by playing games such as British Bulldog and tag, but they will be in danger of minor cuts and bruises, not life threatening conditions such as heart disease and type 2 diabetes. Surely a simple assessment of the two risks reveals what the answer to this question is; lift the ban on British Bulldog.

admin

|

05:36, 02 September 08

|

Karma Score: 14


# 2

Exercise is important for health, but it can be gained by playing other, less violent games than British Bulldog. Football or skipping are non-contact activities that also provide plenty of aerobic exercise without running the risk of broken bones.

admin

|

05:36, 02 September 08

|

Karma Score: 14



2. There are many health benefits to be gained by parents removing the cotton wool from around their children
# 1

Children are meant to be boisterous, they are meant to get dirty and get bruised. In fact, childhood is when people mature their immune system. A child should be exposed to natural dirt so their bodies are equipped to deal with such germs in adult life. So by removing the cotton wool, not only will children’s immune systems gain strength but they will also lose weight and be less likely to suffer from illnesses associated with lack of exercise such as high blood pressure. If we lifted the ban on British Bulldog, perhaps parents would see how their cotton wool is suffocating their child’s health.

admin

|

05:37, 02 September 08

|

Karma Score: 14



3. There are many social benefits too!
# 1

Childhood games such as British Bulldog gave children an opportunity to interact with each other. In a day and age where technology is so advanced it is taking over human interaction, such games are needed so children learn how to behave around other children. If we were to ban all contact games in school playgrounds the only things children would play with at lunch time is personal stereos and handheld games. Children would have no awareness of how they should behave around other children. This lack of social awareness would then be transferred to adult life, making Britain a very isolated place.

British Bulldog is not a focus on violence, but even if someone gets a few cuts and bruises, it will teach them not to be a wimp.

admin

|

05:37, 02 September 08

|

Karma Score: 14


# 2

Games based on violence, like British Bulldog, surely only teach children that the way to get ahead is to use brute force and shove anyone weaker than you out of the way. Unlike team sports, like football or even games like 'Stuck in the mud' where children have to work together, British Bulldog doesn't teach children about team work.

admin

|

05:37, 02 September 08

|

Karma Score: 14



4. Too little exercise
# 1

It's not as if those giving chase are armed. All physical activities should be encouraged, including dancing. What concerns me is the level to which parents bringing their children to school by car is tolerated. Schools should get together with their local Traffic & Transport dept. and ban parking within a half mile radius of each school and children being given lifts (unless they are injured) should be expelled. Children old enough to go to school are old enough to walk there.

ZoePlusCats

|

14:05, 29 August 09

|

Karma Score: 63



5. Let the children play!
# 1

Children are supposed to play when they are young - it helps them develop. Despite popular belief, British Buldog it's a game that teaches you how to deal with agressivity. There are nice people in the world and "not so nice" people. If you don't learn since you're a child to stand up for yourself, than you will never learn. And plus - it is also a game of strategy - ho to catch first, in order to make things easyer.

Oana486

|

06:06, 01 September 09

|

Karma Score: 6



6. Make it safer!
# 1

Of course there are minor bruisers - than make the playground safer. It is easier than to make an invesment from the local autorities to just ban the game. But lets have a better look: all major sports - have accidents : football, baschetball, Boeing, karate and people are still doing it - and let me say: very fit people, who do not suffer of obesity. Thus, in order to help children become fit adults, and in order to keep tradition, British Buldog should not be banned!

Oana486

|

06:12, 01 September 09

|

Karma Score: 6



1. Playground sports will only be detrimental to obese children’s self esteem
# 1

Picking teams is always a traumatic time for the chubby kid; being the last fatty standing. Children are cruel and they may even insist that the obese children are not allowed to play on their team. Such a public rejection by their peers is deeply embarrassing and degrading. Not only will the obese child not play the game on such an occasion, but they would go home with a low self esteem and may comfort eat. Obese children may even comfort eat after a poor performance in one such game at school. Once obese, children need special attention with regard to exercise, not just shoved into the deep pool.

admin

|

05:38, 02 September 08

|

Karma Score: 14


# 2

Yes, children can be cruel, but unfortunately discrimination is part of life. You can't ban any competitive situations just because some people will have to lose; that is no preparation for the real world.

admin

|

05:38, 02 September 08

|

Karma Score: 14



2. compensation culture makes playground sports impossible
# 1

Britain is following America with regard to, among other things, their compensation culture. Places of work are being sued; professionals are being sued and public enterprises such as schools and hospitals are also being sued. If rough and tumble games are played at school, and a child gets hurt, a school could be left in the red after paying out a fortune in compensation. In a growing technological market, education is increasingly important and so educational institutions need to take all the precautions they can to keep open.

admin

|

05:38, 02 September 08

|

Karma Score: 14



3. the answer to obesity lays outside the school’s reach
# 1

As with anything, the buck for obesity is trying to be pushed elsewhere. Now we are hearing the banning of violent games from school playgrounds is to blame! However, boys were the main players of such games whilst girls sat around crayoning and plaiting hair. But girls were no more obese than boys back when obesity was described as an epidemic. So this shows that the banning of British Bulldog in playgrounds was not the cause of obesity and so lifting the ban will not be the solution to obesity.

admin

|

05:38, 02 September 08

|

Karma Score: 14



4. Lifestyle changes are needed, not child’s play
# 1

Merely lifting the ban on violent games such as British Bulldog will make no difference to our obesity epidemic. For a start, it is only helping children; obese parents need to be helped. If a child witnesses their parent slobbing on the sofa constantly when at school they will exhibit the same behaviour, regardless of whether contact games are allowed in the playground.

The energy that would be used by exercising in lunch time may not be enough for binging Britain. If the parents remained uneducated about food, and packing a stodgy pack lunch for their obese child, a game of British Bulldog may not even burn off the calories of the lunch, let alone their breakfast and tea.

Unfortunately there are no quick solutions to obesity, we need a British reformation.

admin

|

05:38, 02 September 08

|

Karma Score: 14



Loading...