Modified:
26 Nov 2009
by Admin

Vote totals:

Yes:

0%

No:

0%

Neutral:

0%

 
Subscribe to This Debate
You are not currently subscribed to this debate.


Subscribe to Newsletter
Tell a Friend
(Use commas to separate)
Bookmark and Share


DEBATE: ARE REALITY SHOWS A CONFIDENCE BOOSTER FOR THEIR PARTICIPANTS?

We love to hate reality stars and some of the criticism levelled at them can be unbelievable - particularly in online forums. But can the process be a confidence booster or will they need years of therapy afterwards?





ARE REALITY SHOWS A CONFIDENCE BOOSTER FOR THEIR PARTICIPANTS?


Popularity leads to confidence


If someone goes on a show like big brother and the public love them, they will clearly get a boost to their self-esteem - the approval of others is a key factor in self-confidence.

It could be argued, though, that to go on a reality show in the first place one must have a reasonable level of confidence already. So the show isn't making people more confident it is just giving them a place to showcase their already strong character.


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Yes
Strongly Yes
Mostly Yes
Partially Yes
Neutral
Partially No
Mostly No
Strongly No
Absolutely No

ARE REALITY SHOWS A CONFIDENCE BOOSTER FOR THEIR PARTICIPANTS?


The exposure on reality TV forces a level of self-acceptance


In everyday life we present a certain 'face' to those around us, not revealing everything about ourselves. Yet in the environment of a reality TV programme, there is nowhere to hide; not only are you often cooped up with the same group of people 24/7, but cameras capture aspects of your life that are normally private. You are often placed in high pressure situations with no opportunity to hide your emotional reactions. To be accepted 'warts and all' by people who have seen you arguably at your worst is the biggest complement there can be. It reinforces the idea that the 'real' you is perfectly acceptable and something to be proud of.

Far from self-acceptance, these brutal levels of exposure can lead to doubt and self-loathing. Watching the footage, people see aspects of themselves they never normally would; they are forced to see themselves drunk, argumentative, or looking dodgy first thing in the morning. Their image of themselves is shattered by the often ugly reality, which leads to poor self-esteem.


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Yes
Strongly Yes
Mostly Yes
Partially Yes
Neutral
Partially No
Mostly No
Strongly No
Absolutely No

ARE REALITY SHOWS A CONFIDENCE BOOSTER FOR THEIR PARTICIPANTS?


The amount of votes


The fact that in 2008 more people participated in voting for the BBC's 'Strictly Come Dancing' than in the 2005 General Elections must allow the participants of the show to feel content about gaining more interest than politics. This is not surprising though when we have a PM like Gordon Brown or opposition such as David Cameron and Nick Clegg.



ARE REALITY SHOWS A CONFIDENCE BOOSTER FOR THEIR PARTICIPANTS?


Unpopularity can damage fragile self-esteem


Feeling disliked by others will always have a negative effect, whether on reality TV or in real-life situations. Being unpopular amongst your school mates is arguable a more damaging eventuality than being voted out of Big Brother. The fact that you were chosen to participate and have received any recognition at all should be enough to feed most people' s egos; even 'hate' figures like original Big Brother baddie 'Nasty Nick' or 2007's terrifying Charley achieve a kind of notoriety. They are people we 'love to hate'; it is a perverse kind of public affection.

If, on the other hand someone goes on a reality show and is disliked by the general public, their morale, self-esteem and confidence may suffer as a result. If people don't like you, you start to question why, and question yourself, and your confidence nose-dives.


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Yes
Strongly Yes
Mostly Yes
Partially Yes
Neutral
Partially No
Mostly No
Strongly No
Absolutely No

ARE REALITY SHOWS A CONFIDENCE BOOSTER FOR THEIR PARTICIPANTS?


Transient fame is not the same as genuine popularity


Some reality TV stars go on to have long careers in the media, having been given the confidence and exposure by their initial experiences. Jane Macdonald, who's career began on the Cruise Ship fly-on-the wall documentary, went on to have a Platinum album and now presents ITV's Loose Women. Big Brother winner Brian Dowling has had a successful presenting career. Before her slightly disastrous return to Big Brother (a particularly exceptional case) Jade Goody had carved a very profitable career out of her appearance on reality TV.

While the approval and affection of your peers might be a confidence boost, the effect of having been on a reality show is very different. While for five minutes you might feel popular, in reality your new 'celebrity' status will isolate you from your real friends. When the public gets bored of you, or worse, the press becomes hostile towards you in search of a better story, it will be a crushing blow; you will have gained nothing and lost the sense of security you had before you became 'famous.'


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Yes
Strongly Yes
Mostly Yes
Partially Yes
Neutral
Partially No
Mostly No
Strongly No
Absolutely No

ARE REALITY SHOWS A CONFIDENCE BOOSTER FOR THEIR PARTICIPANTS?


Popularity does not necessarily guarantee high self-esteem


Just because the public loves you, that does not mean that you will love yourself. Self-esteem stems from much more than the approval of others. Although it certainly helps, sometimes someone can be very popular, but think very ltitle of themselves.



ARE REALITY SHOWS A CONFIDENCE BOOSTER FOR THEIR PARTICIPANTS?


Competitions for money tend to bring out the worst in people-causes violence and spite!


On the other hand competitions with prizes do tend to cause shyer or otherwise un-known people to speak up, get counted. This can lead to them getting a higher self-estem in the long run.

Competitions for money tend to bring out the worst in people-it can cause violence and spite! The contestants would do this when it becomes closer to the final votes. It might even bring out the worst in the viewers sometimes, most of the time they watch it to see people humiliate themselves because they gt a kick out of it. this goes back to our primal insticnts that violence is good and laughing at other peoples expense is fun.


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Yes
Strongly Yes
Mostly Yes
Partially Yes
Neutral
Partially No
Mostly No
Strongly No
Absolutely No


Vote on the overall debate: Are reality shows a confidence booster for their participants?

What do you think?  Vote on this debate below.
Absolutely Yes
Strongly Yes
Mostly Yes
Partially Yes
Neutral
Partially No
Mostly No
Strongly No
Absolutely No
1. Popularity leads to confidence
# 1

If someone goes on a show like big brother and the public love them, they will clearly get a boost to their self-esteem - the approval of others is a key factor in self-confidence.

admin

|

12:24, 24 July 08

|

Karma Score: 14


# 2

It could be argued, though, that to go on a reality show in the first place one must have a reasonable level of confidence already. So the show isn't making people more confident it is just giving them a place to showcase their already strong character.

admin

|

12:24, 24 July 08

|

Karma Score: 14



2. The exposure on reality TV forces a level of self-acceptance
# 1

In everyday life we present a certain 'face' to those around us, not revealing everything about ourselves. Yet in the environment of a reality TV programme, there is nowhere to hide; not only are you often cooped up with the same group of people 24/7, but cameras capture aspects of your life that are normally private. You are often placed in high pressure situations with no opportunity to hide your emotional reactions. To be accepted 'warts and all' by people who have seen you arguably at your worst is the biggest complement there can be. It reinforces the idea that the 'real' you is perfectly acceptable and something to be proud of.

admin

|

06:32, 25 July 08

|

Karma Score: 14


# 2

Far from self-acceptance, these brutal levels of exposure can lead to doubt and self-loathing. Watching the footage, people see aspects of themselves they never normally would; they are forced to see themselves drunk, argumentative, or looking dodgy first thing in the morning. Their image of themselves is shattered by the often ugly reality, which leads to poor self-esteem.

admin

|

06:32, 25 July 08

|

Karma Score: 14



3. The amount of votes
# 1

The fact that in 2008 more people participated in voting for the BBC's 'Strictly Come Dancing' than in the 2005 General Elections must allow the participants of the show to feel content about gaining more interest than politics. This is not surprising though when we have a PM like Gordon Brown or opposition such as David Cameron and Nick Clegg.

admin

|

09:15, 03 May 09

|

Karma Score: 14



1. Unpopularity can damage fragile self-esteem
# 1

If, on the other hand someone goes on a reality show and is disliked by the general public, their morale, self-esteem and confidence may suffer as a result. If people don't like you, you start to question why, and question yourself, and your confidence nose-dives.

admin

|

12:28, 24 July 08

|

Karma Score: 14


# 2

Feeling disliked by others will always have a negative effect, whether on reality TV or in real-life situations. Being unpopular amongst your school mates is arguable a more damaging eventuality than being voted out of Big Brother. The fact that you were chosen to participate and have received any recognition at all should be enough to feed most people' s egos; even 'hate' figures like original Big Brother baddie 'Nasty Nick' or 2007's terrifying Charley achieve a kind of notoriety. They are people we 'love to hate'; it is a perverse kind of public affection.

admin

|

12:28, 24 July 08

|

Karma Score: 14



2. Transient fame is not the same as genuine popularity
# 1

While the approval and affection of your peers might be a confidence boost, the effect of having been on a reality show is very different. While for five minutes you might feel popular, in reality your new 'celebrity' status will isolate you from your real friends. When the public gets bored of you, or worse, the press becomes hostile towards you in search of a better story, it will be a crushing blow; you will have gained nothing and lost the sense of security you had before you became 'famous.'

admin

|

06:17, 25 July 08

|

Karma Score: 14


# 2

Some reality TV stars go on to have long careers in the media, having been given the confidence and exposure by their initial experiences. Jane Macdonald, who's career began on the Cruise Ship fly-on-the wall documentary, went on to have a Platinum album and now presents ITV's Loose Women. Big Brother winner Brian Dowling has had a successful presenting career. Before her slightly disastrous return to Big Brother (a particularly exceptional case) Jade Goody had carved a very profitable career out of her appearance on reality TV.

admin

|

06:17, 25 July 08

|

Karma Score: 14



3. Popularity does not necessarily guarantee high self-esteem
# 1

Just because the public loves you, that does not mean that you will love yourself. Self-esteem stems from much more than the approval of others. Although it certainly helps, sometimes someone can be very popular, but think very ltitle of themselves.

admin

|

13:19, 26 July 08

|

Karma Score: 14



4. Competitions for money tend to bring out the worst in people-causes violence and spite!
# 1

Competitions for money tend to bring out the worst in people-causes violence and spite!

chaudhry

|

18:07, 26 November 09

|

Karma Score: 16


# 2

On the other hand competitions with prizes do tend to cause shyer or otherwise un-known people to speak up, get counted. This can lead to them getting a higher self-estem in the long run.

chaudhry

|

18:12, 26 November 09

|

Karma Score: 16



Loading...