Modified:
25 Nov 2009
by Admin
Vote totals:
Yes:
80%
No:
20%
Neutral:
0%
Subscribe to This Debate
You are not currently subscribed to this debate.
Misc Debates
Subscribe to Newsletter
Tell a Friend
(Use commas to separate)
DEBATE: VEGETARIANISM CAN SAVE THE WORLD FROM GLOBAL WARMING AND POVERTY
Posted by: flicdabug
Karma:
40
If everyone stopped eating meat or cut down considerably we would.......
1. cut CO2 emmisions which means global warming will be reduced.
2. reduce land degredation this means that land would not be destroyed beyond repair.
3. Reduce water pollution, through run-off i.e hormones getting into the water, animal waste polluting the water and chemicals from tanneries, fertilizers and pesticides.
4. Also if we stopped producing vast amounts of crops to feed the livestock people are going to eat and produced the crops for human consumption we could end world hunger.
Executive Summary
Join The Debate
All the Yes points
All the No points
VEGETARIANISM CAN SAVE THE WORLD FROM GLOBAL WARMING AND POVERTY
Cut CO2 emissions
18 percent of CO2 equivalent green house gas emissions are generated by the livestock sector: that is more than how much cars emit.The livestock sector accounts for 9 percent of CO2 emissions derived from human related activities, but this produces an even larger share of more harmful greenhouse gasses. It generates 65 percent of human related nitrous oxide which has 296 times the global warming potential of CO2: most of the CO2 potential comes from manure
Global warming is a hoax.
there is no real evidence of global warming whan looked at over the cumulative history of the earth. the earth has always gone thriugh periods of warm ages and cold ages. the last cold age was 10000yrs ago. the next will be in 15000yrs, so we have 2,500 yrs of warmingbefore cooling down. furthermore, the carbon levels in the atmosphere have also always been fluxing as have oxygen and nitrate levels in the atmosphrere. the whole of the earth was a lot hotter in the past when the dinosaurs were around, than it is now, and since humans hve only been around for the past 10,000yrs, it appears to us as if the earth is warming, but to the world itself, it is not.
What do you think? Vote on this point below.
VEGETARIANISM CAN SAVE THE WORLD FROM GLOBAL WARMING AND POVERTY
Land degradation
This happens on many farms when dealing with livestock. It can occur when land is over grazed, which applies to 20 percent of pastures that are used by livestock. This figure rises if you take into account land which is subjected to desertification when policies are not followed and livestock are overgrazed on drylands. The likelihood of the land being restored to a useable state where it is able to support crops is small. It takes years to get back the nutrients which have been leeched from the soil. Compaction and erosion also need to be taken into account as cattle will destroy land/soil just by walking on it. Over long periods of time this process destroys aggregates, the land becomes unusable, and desertification is inevitable. Erosion speaks for itself; it can make land unusable for years or even decades.
VEGETARIANISM CAN SAVE THE WORLD FROM GLOBAL WARMING AND POVERTY
Water Pollution
Livestock runoff accounts for huge amounts of water pollution: be it waste from tanneries, fertilizers, pesticides, hormones or manure. If we did not use land for keeping cattle but purely for crops we would cut the pollutants going into the water systems by over half. In the South China Sea livestock is the main contributor to the phosphorous and nitrogen contamination of the inland waters. If this is allowed to continue without the government stepping in to put policies in place, water pollution will continue and the biodiversity of water systems will be beyond repair.
VEGETARIANISM CAN SAVE THE WORLD FROM GLOBAL WARMING AND POVERTY
Ridiculous
This can't be true because plants ABSORB CO2 from the air, so essentially eating more plants is allowing more CO2 to go into the ozone. Plus meat is essential to human stability providing necessary protein and calories which a vegitarian diet can't provide.
Are you stupid? Nitrogen oxide and methane is more lethal than C02 which induces global warming a hell of a lot more. It's better to have C02 in the air than the nitrogen oxide and methane created from the manure, fertilizers, hormones and pesticides.We'd have to grow the plants before we could eat them and continue growing them to meet the demand, so arguably there would be more plants than there are now at any given time, despite increased consumption.
What do you think? Vote on this point below.
VEGETARIANISM CAN SAVE THE WORLD FROM GLOBAL WARMING AND POVERTY
Some people need meat
Some people need the concentrated protein and iron found in meat, such as women during their reproductive years, teens etc. Even the Dalai Lama was advised by his doctor to eat a bit of chicken.
VEGETARIANISM CAN SAVE THE WORLD FROM GLOBAL WARMING AND POVERTY
Meat is an essential part of a balanced diet
In this day and age westerners don't need to eat meat. We can get our protein from other sources such as tofu, which contains more protein than any meat source. Also pulses, nuts, seeds and grains offer plenty of protein to keep a diet balanced. The first man did not eat meat and only had teeth for grazing on vegetable matter with the odd insect thrown in. It was only as man learnt to hunt that they realised they could get other food sources and we slowly evolved to have teeth that where made for eating meat: before this we had grinding molars. Now we do not need to hunt to survive and we have other options to eat, therefore there is no need to eat meat. I strongly believe that if you can't kill it you should not eat it. What gives someone the right to think, ‘okay, I will just go and get my meat from the shop and not give a thought about the process by which it came to be on the supermarket shelf’? We do not even consider how it has affected the land on which it grazed and how much tonnage of vegetation (which could have been used for human consumption on a much smaller scale) was used to feed one animal. We don't NEED to eat meat to survive. If everyone cut back or gave up we would be saving the planet and helping to end poverty.
Meat provides protein and has formed a fundamental part of the human diet since the very first humans. We need it to survive.~~~
Who ever wrote the above is stupid. Not only is it a weak arguement, but it has already been proven wrong. No comparison between the left and this one.
What do you think? Vote on this point below.
VEGETARIANISM CAN SAVE THE WORLD FROM GLOBAL WARMING AND POVERTY
If humans stopped eating meat, the world's ecosystem would be thrown off.
The world's eco system revolves around animals eating animals. It stops certain animals--such as rabits and vermin--from over populating the world. Animals have eaten other animals since the beginning of time. It's only natural.If humans stopped eating meat, the world's ecosystem would be totally thrown off. What would we do with all of the factory farmed cows if we're not going to eat them? We wouldn't have any use for them asides from using them as milking cows, but that only puts the female cows to use. That makes about one half of the cows useless. We wouldn't have anything to do with them asides from set them free, into the wild. In America, where many factory famrs are, cows don't have any natural predators. This would make cows take over the continent like an invasive plant. Cows would wipe out all of the native species that live in the US and would, therefore, throw off the eco system. Imagine this situation with every single farm animal. Soon enough, there would be no native plant or animal species because millions of factory farm animals were set free.
Vote on the overall debate: Vegetarianism can save the world from global warming and poverty
What do you think? Vote on this debate below.

dhc
|14:13, 28 May 08
|Karma Score: 1367
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
global warming is a hoax
|14:48, 20 October 09
|Karma Score: 3
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
dhc
|14:22, 28 May 08
|Karma Score: 1367
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
dhc
|14:30, 28 May 08
|Karma Score: 1367
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
admin
|09:50, 27 September 08
|Karma Score: 14
|Applause: 1
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
admin
|09:50, 27 September 08
|Karma Score: 14
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
admin
|04:06, 15 December 08
|Karma Score: 14
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
dhc
|10:39, 04 June 08
|Karma Score: 1367
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
dhc
|10:39, 04 June 08
|Karma Score: 1367
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
Vegetables
|16:56, 31 May 09
|Karma Score: 3
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply