Modified:
20 Nov 2009
by Nadia999

Vote totals:

Yes:

67%

No:

33%

Neutral:

0%

 
Subscribe to This Debate
You are not currently subscribed to this debate.


Subscribe to Newsletter
Tell a Friend
(Use commas to separate)
Bookmark and Share


DEBATE: DOES EROTIC EQUAL PORNOGRAPHIC?

A distinction is often made between Erotica and Pornography, although depending on the viewer; they may seem to be one and the same. Where do we draw the line between Erotica and Pornography?





DOES EROTIC EQUAL PORNOGRAPHIC?


Erotica is different from pornography in objective, purpose and symbolic content.


There is a clear distinction between what is erotic and what is pornographic. Pornography’s objective is the graphic depiction of sexually explicit scenes. It is a detailed and naturalistic image, a verbal description or a demonstration of a sexual intercourse and/or genitals with an end purpose to arouse sexual excitement in a human being, usually, in exchange for money. It can also be exploitative or degrading. Its symbolic content is very limited and focused on sex only. Erotica’s objective, on the other hand is the portrayal of human anatomy and sexuality in a more multi-layered and polysemic way. It seeks to tell a story with sexual themes and evocative imagery. Its purpose is to explore desire, love, sexuality, human anatomy and passion through mystery and intrigue. It is because of these clear dissimilitudes which we can define them as separate entities.

The difference is very subtle. Pornography could be classed as anything showing nudity. Hence erotica, displaying nudity, would fit into this category.


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Yes
Strongly Yes
Mostly Yes
Partially Yes
Neutral
Partially No
Mostly No
Strongly No
Absolutely No

DOES EROTIC EQUAL PORNOGRAPHIC?


Pornography is symbolically flat. Erotica is polysemic.


Pornography is symbolically unidimensional. It has only one purpose and objective, which is to sexually arouse the viewer. Erotica, on the other hand, is polysemic. It has several layers of meaning. Either depicted in paint, film, song, music, photography, sculpture, poetry, literature or the spoken word, the audience can relate to the piece in several different levels, possibly but not necessarily sexual, and can reflect upon its alternative meanings. "What's the difference between erotic art and pornography? Lots of people want to ban pornography but no one really talks about banning erotic art. Both are representations. How do we draw the line between "good" erotica and "bad" pornography? John gives a definition of both the erotic the pornographic. Why does pornography have the extremely negative connotation? Ken puts forth the idea that a lot of negative reaction to erotic art is out of fear for the power of the erotic."-[1]

Pornography usually evacuates love,commitment, closeness,kindness and goodness out of sex.It is cheap and designates cheap thrills, as such. Porn/porno depicts very limited story-lines which end in a death or an orgasm. The viewer after a few porn films becomes desensitized and needs more and more sex to be aroused or could fail to be aroused altogether in the long run(You start viewing porn at 14 and say bye-bye to arousal at twenty, when you actually have sex.). Impotency/infertility is a huge problem, rooted a lot of the time, in the psychological drawbacks of viewing porn.

However, erotica only delves into how sex is a natural impulse and a part of a much larger,fuller,complex,interesting and deeper story. It depicts sex as a fact of life,like eating or defecating. It's normal, it does not end in a heart-attack or murder or orgasm. It does not involve extreme exercise or acrobatics.It is just the act of 'lovemaking': An act of secure,maybe dangerous but largely realistic tenderness.People do not suffer psychologically from erotica.
  1. ^ http://www.philosophytalk.org/pastShows/eroticpornographic.htm



DOES EROTIC EQUAL PORNOGRAPHIC?


Erotica is an art, pornography is an industry.


Erotica is part of us being human. It is done for the art of portraying human sexuality. It is an art. It is done to explore the senses. Pornography’s objective is sexual pleasure. It is an industry whose sole concern is not being artistic or creative but in making money from an audience.



DOES EROTIC EQUAL PORNOGRAPHIC?


Erotica is pornography


traditional 'families' would not be 'families', if they didn't view or relate to sex as a fact of life. Where in religion is voyeurism prohibited? Where does it say do not talk or write about sex? All the scribes of every holy book wrote about sex, and rules about sex. Examples: do not covet thy neighbor's wife, do not bed another man, do not commit adultery. Erotic art does not deal solely in sex and is much truer to life than pornography. Erotic art is artistic, it arouses appreciation and not an erection. You might as well argue that nudism/naturalism is the same as striptease.

Erotica is Pornography because at the end they both have a corrupting impact on viewers/consumers. They both have a corrosive effect on traditional family and religious values. Erotic art is pornography and is not redeemed by other artistic, literary or political merit which the work might posses because the outcome is the same. Any sexual material is obscene, erotica and pornography are both based on sexually explicit material, therefore they are both one and same.


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Yes
Strongly Yes
Mostly Yes
Partially Yes
Neutral
Partially No
Mostly No
Strongly No
Absolutely No

DOES EROTIC EQUAL PORNOGRAPHIC?


Both erotica and pornography are one and the same, and therefore harmful to society.


How does erotica corrupt one's morals?

'They have one end meaning, explicit or implicit which lies in obscenity and therefore harmful to society.'- by this argument life itself is obscene. You're saying that having sex in your boudoir(implicit) is the same as having sex on the street(explicit). You might as well ban sex all together and we all know the problems sexually-repressed people have.

Both erotica and pornography are one and the same because they are both harmful to its consumers by corrupting their morals and making them less likely to be able to have a long-term, loving relationship. They have one end meaning, explicit or implicit which lies in obscenity and therefore harmful to society.


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Yes
Strongly Yes
Mostly Yes
Partially Yes
Neutral
Partially No
Mostly No
Strongly No
Absolutely No

DOES EROTIC EQUAL PORNOGRAPHIC?


Erotica and pornography are both harmful industries.


Erotica does not involve the torture of women. These feminists do not object to erotica. In fact most lesbian(non-bi) feminists are quite content with erotica depicting women enjoying eachother.

According to anti-pornography feminists, pornography is not just a harmless entertainment or a cathartic, therapeutic fantasy. Unlike moral conservatives, who object to pornography on the grounds of the obscenity of its sexual explicit content and its corrosive effect on the conservative way of life, the primary focus of the feminist objection to pornography is on the central role that pornography is thought to play in the exploitation and oppression of women. Because erotica is so linked to pornography, it would suggest that they are both harmful industries.


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Yes
Strongly Yes
Mostly Yes
Partially Yes
Neutral
Partially No
Mostly No
Strongly No
Absolutely No

DOES EROTIC EQUAL PORNOGRAPHIC?



What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Yes
Strongly Yes
Mostly Yes
Partially Yes
Neutral
Partially No
Mostly No
Strongly No
Absolutely No


Vote on the overall debate: Does erotic equal pornographic?

What do you think?  Vote on this debate below.
Absolutely Yes
Strongly Yes
Mostly Yes
Partially Yes
Neutral
Partially No
Mostly No
Strongly No
Absolutely No
1. Erotica is different from pornography in objective, purpose and symbolic content.
# 1

There is a clear distinction between what is erotic and what is pornographic. Pornography’s objective is the graphic depiction of sexually explicit scenes. It is a detailed and naturalistic image, a verbal description or a demonstration of a sexual intercourse and/or genitals with an end purpose to arouse sexual excitement in a human being, usually, in exchange for money. It can also be exploitative or degrading. Its symbolic content is very limited and focused on sex only. Erotica’s objective, on the other hand is the portrayal of human anatomy and sexuality in a more multi-layered and polysemic way. It seeks to tell a story with sexual themes and evocative imagery. Its purpose is to explore desire, love, sexuality, human anatomy and passion through mystery and intrigue. It is because of these clear dissimilitudes which we can define them as separate entities.

dhc

|

13:09, 08 May 08

|

Karma Score: 1367


# 2

The difference is very subtle. Pornography could be classed as anything showing nudity. Hence erotica, displaying nudity, would fit into this category.

dhc

|

13:09, 08 May 08

|

Karma Score: 1367



2. Pornography is symbolically flat. Erotica is polysemic.
# 1

Pornography is symbolically unidimensional. It has only one purpose and objective, which is to sexually arouse the viewer. Erotica, on the other hand, is polysemic. It has several layers of meaning. Either depicted in paint, film, song, music, photography, sculpture, poetry, literature or the spoken word, the audience can relate to the piece in several different levels, possibly but not necessarily sexual, and can reflect upon its alternative meanings.

dhc

|

14:10, 08 May 08

|

Karma Score: 1367



3. Erotica is an art, pornography is an industry.
# 1

Erotica is part of us being human. It is done for the art of portraying human sexuality. It is an art. It is done to explore the senses. Pornography’s objective is sexual pleasure. It is an industry whose sole concern is not being artistic or creative but in making money from an audience.

dhc

|

16:51, 08 May 08

|

Karma Score: 1367



1. Erotica is pornography
# 1

Erotica is Pornography because at the end they both have a corrupting impact on viewers/consumers. They both have a corrosive effect on traditional family and religious values. Erotic art is pornography and is not redeemed by other artistic, literary or political merit which the work might posses because the outcome is the same. Any sexual material is obscene, erotica and pornography are both based on sexually explicit material, therefore they are both one and same.

dhc

|

16:44, 08 May 08

|

Karma Score: 1367


# 2

traditional 'families' would not be 'families', if they didn't view or relate to sex as a fact of life. Where in religion is voyeurism prohibited? Where does it say do not talk or write about sex? All the scribes of every holy book wrote about sex, and rules about sex. Examples: do not covet thy neighbor's wife, do not bed another man, do not commit adultery. Erotic art does not deal solely in sex and is much truer to life than pornography. Erotic art is artistic, it arouses appreciation and not an erection. You might as well argue that nudism/naturalism is the same as striptease.

NADIA999

|

07:22, 18 August 09

|

Karma Score: 5609



2. Both erotica and pornography are one and the same, and therefore harmful to society.
# 1

Both erotica and pornography are one and the same because they are both harmful to its consumers by corrupting their morals and making them less likely to be able to have a long-term, loving relationship. They have one end meaning, explicit or implicit which lies in obscenity and therefore harmful to society.

dhc

|

17:00, 08 May 08

|

Karma Score: 1367


# 2

How does erotica corrupt one's morals?

'They have one end meaning, explicit or implicit which lies in obscenity and therefore harmful to society.'- by this argument life itself is obscene. You're saying that having sex in your boudoir(implicit) is the same as having sex on the street(explicit). You might as well ban sex all together and we all know the problems sexually-repressed people have.

NADIA999

|

07:29, 18 August 09

|

Karma Score: 5609



3. Erotica and pornography are both harmful industries.
# 1

According to anti-pornography feminists, pornography is not just a harmless entertainment or a cathartic, therapeutic fantasy. Unlike moral conservatives, who object to pornography on the grounds of the obscenity of its sexual explicit content and its corrosive effect on the conservative way of life, the primary focus of the feminist objection to pornography is on the central role that pornography is thought to play in the exploitation and oppression of women. Because erotica is so linked to pornography, it would suggest that they are both harmful industries.

dhc

|

17:07, 08 May 08

|

Karma Score: 1367


# 2

Erotica does not involve the torture of women. These feminists do not object to erotica.

NADIA999

|

07:24, 18 August 09

|

Karma Score: 5609



4. I like porno
# 1

YEA

admin

|

11:11, 10 September 08

|

Karma Score: 14


# 2

me too

admin

|

11:11, 10 September 08

|

Karma Score: 14



Loading...