Modified:
08 Nov 2009
by Admin
Vote totals:
Yes:
29%
No:
71%
Neutral:
0%
Subscribe to This Debate
You are not currently subscribed to this debate.
Misc Debates
Subscribe to Newsletter
Tell a Friend
(Use commas to separate)
DEBATE: THIS HOUSE BELIEVES BRITAIN SHOULD JOIN THE EUROPEAN SINGLE CURRENCY
Posted by: Lagunium
Karma:
12
This debate looks at the benefits and points against Britain joining the single currency, a debate that has at times dominated, and at times fallen under the radar of mainstream British Politics.
Executive Summary
Join The Debate
All the Yes points
All the No points
THIS HOUSE BELIEVES BRITAIN SHOULD JOIN THE EUROPEAN SINGLE CURRENCY
Reduces transaction costs
At present to trade within the EU we need to change currencies in order to complete any deals with other states. This leads to trade having large costs associated with the raw transaction, deterring trade. In addition, if there are large currency swings between the agreement and completion of the trade one side can lose out, ultimately having a deterrent effect.
This is overstated. Costs are usually minimal and any gains made here would be lost owing to the loss of investment.
GBP Sterling has long been one of the strongest currencies in the world, lower transaction costs are in no way beneficial enough for us to lose the overall buying power that sterling gives us in the international market place, even whilst we have been in the longest period of recesion on record Sterling has remained a very strong currency. I dont think it is beneficial to our economy to lose this strength, it speaks for itself when other countries with much healthier economies do not have a means of exchange as strong as ours. To lose this edge in the international market place would be a tremendous blow to the UK and reduce our economic standing in Europe. For the UK to give up our currency just so we wouldnt have to pay exchange rates when we go on holiday beggers belief.
What do you think? Vote on this point below.
THIS HOUSE BELIEVES BRITAIN SHOULD JOIN THE EUROPEAN SINGLE CURRENCY
Brings us closer to the EU, giving us political clout
The EU is, if we like it or not fast becoming one of the major political bodies in the world. The UK needs to be able to have an effective say in it if it is to work for our benefit and joining the Euro is a sign we are willing to be a participate in the European Government process.Being a member of the Euro would demonstrate to our European allies that we are at last prepared to play the path we should of played in Europe many years ago. We would also gain from Euro membership by an increased voice in Europe and increased power over issues such as appointments to the new posts of European President and Foreign and Security High Representative as is currently taking place.
You do not need to have integration in order to have cooperation. We’ve been working closely with other states for many years now, and damaging our economy by joining the single currency isn’t going to make any difference to that.
What do you think? Vote on this point below.
THIS HOUSE BELIEVES BRITAIN SHOULD JOIN THE EUROPEAN SINGLE CURRENCY
Price competition
With a single currency opportunities for investment are actually increased. Citizens can move their money from one country to another far more easily, meaning that people can take advantage of situations where goods are cheaper than elsewhere in the EU more effectively (booze cruises being a good example.) As such, price competition takes place and people will save money.
The empirical evidence shows that aside from booze-cruises from the UK to France, transport costs outweigh any savings in the Euro Zone and people do not in reality do this, therefore no money is saved and the point is invalid.
What do you think? Vote on this point below.
THIS HOUSE BELIEVES BRITAIN SHOULD JOIN THE EUROPEAN SINGLE CURRENCY
Eases and simplifies european travel and business
In a globalising world the differences between territories are becoming smaller and smaller, and traffic in terms of goods resources and people is becoming a constant flow between their neighbouring states. We should help ease this flow by eliminating currency conversion as it is an unneccesary adjustment that just adds to the stress of this transition.
This argument assumes that globalisation is a positive development and should be eased along its way. Globalisation, however, is a force that will lead to the assimilation of many valuable national nuances and varied ways of life, into one homogenous cultural mess. The adoption of the single country, for Britain, would be a step in this direction.
What do you think? Vote on this point below.
THIS HOUSE BELIEVES BRITAIN SHOULD JOIN THE EUROPEAN SINGLE CURRENCY
Joining the Euro would protect against economic and currency shocks
By joining the Euro we would benefit from protection against shocks to our economy and possible runs on our currency. Iceland recently suffered both as a result of the economic crash and is now wishing to join the EU and the Euro to protect it from future shocks. Ireland has also suffered severe economic woes as a result of the economic crash and as a result of being a member of the Euro has avoided the same fate as Iceland.
THIS HOUSE BELIEVES BRITAIN SHOULD JOIN THE EUROPEAN SINGLE CURRENCY
It exposes us to a "one size fits all" interest rate.
This is a rare blip amongst countries that are very converged in their economic cycles, and will to an even larger extent as the time of the Euro goes on.
If Britain enters the Euro, one of the requirements is that control over monetary policy (the control of the money supply to the British economy) must be handed over to the ECB (European Central Bank.) The purpose of monetary policy in modern economics is to speed or slow consumer spending in order to balance competing factors of economic growth and inflation. The argument on this point therefore rests on the case that the economies of the EU states are similar (or converged) enough to have a "one size fits all policy."Example: The best practical example that emphasizes this is Southern Ireland (which was grappling with double figure inflation) and Germany (which had major unemployment problems at the same time.) One state needs interest rates to move one way, the other needs them to move the other, therefore this is unworkable.
What do you think? Vote on this point below.
THIS HOUSE BELIEVES BRITAIN SHOULD JOIN THE EUROPEAN SINGLE CURRENCY
It will distort investment patterns such as FDI
The EU Commission has effectively used the money of member-states to revive depressed areas and breathe new life into this. This coupled with the strong internal investment community, most notably the core financial centres of London and Frankfurt mean this is an overblown argument which will not become an issue.
When countries begin to decline economically and unemployment rises there are normally patterns that go along with this, such as the currency of that country becoming cheaper because of declining trade. This means a price signal is sent to the free market, and investors will seek to put money in as it highlights a weak area that can be revitalised, and money can be made from both the currency movements and the growth of industry. If we have the Euro, this patterns are less obvious, meaning investment is either likely to go outside the Euro Zone where higher returns can be made, or simply not be noticed. In either case, this will hinder economic recovery and prolong unemployment in the depressed area.
What do you think? Vote on this point below.
THIS HOUSE BELIEVES BRITAIN SHOULD JOIN THE EUROPEAN SINGLE CURRENCY
National Identity Argument
Traditionalism is all well and good, but doesn't hold any practical value in the real world - the Euro is a real solution to things such as improving economic growth.National identity is a growing thing, a constantly changing concept. Perhaps it is time for part of Britain's identity to include the word 'European'.Notions of using our national identity as an excuse not to participate further in the EU is just empty rhetoric, we can be both British and European. There is no contradiction between the two and we should push this argument further.
The argument states that one way we define ourselves as a state is through our currency. In joining the Euro we lose that sense of "Britain" and see a cultural loss in a state which is already struggling with an identity problem.
What do you think? Vote on this point below.
Vote on the overall debate: This house believes Britain should join the European Single Currency
What do you think? Vote on this debate below.

dhc
|10:03, 16 April 08
|Karma Score: 1367
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
dhc
|10:03, 16 April 08
|Karma Score: 1367
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
dhc
|10:06, 16 April 08
|Karma Score: 1367
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
dhc
|10:06, 16 April 08
|Karma Score: 1367
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
dhc
|10:12, 16 April 08
|Karma Score: 1367
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
dhc
|10:12, 16 April 08
|Karma Score: 1367
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
dhc
|10:13, 16 April 08
|Karma Score: 1367
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
dhc
|10:13, 16 April 08
|Karma Score: 1367
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
SJH1988
|22:08, 29 October 09
|Karma Score: 400
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
dhc
|09:34, 16 April 08
|Karma Score: 1367
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
dhc
|09:34, 16 April 08
|Karma Score: 1367
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
dhc
|09:43, 16 April 08
|Karma Score: 1367
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
dhc
|09:43, 16 April 08
|Karma Score: 1367
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
dhc
|09:56, 16 April 08
|Karma Score: 1367
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply
dhc
|09:56, 16 April 08
|Karma Score: 1367
Applaud
Quote
Flag
Reply