- + Arnavnarian voted on a point for the debate Foreign workers should be given the right to vote in local elections where they work.
- + Tracy Barret voted on the debate Prostitution should be legalised to protect sex workers from HIV/AIDS
- + Plally7 edited the debate Will mankind make it to the next century?
- + Arnavnarian voted on a point for the debate Foreign workers should be given the right to vote in local elections where they work.
- + Arnavnarian voted on a point for the debate Foreign workers should be given the right to vote in local elections where they work.
- + Arnavnarian voted on a point for the debate Foreign workers should be given the right to vote in local elections where they work.
- + Arnavnarian joined Debatewise
- + Ll Blynch edited the debate Are London Underground staff justified in their strike action?
- + Golmindalin joined Debatewise
AID TO HAITI SHOULD FOCUS ON REBUILDING INSTITUTIONS NOT BUILDINGS.
Just rebuilding the buildings of Haiti is not enough, instead there needs to be a comprehensive effort aimed at improving the lives of the people in Haiti. This means stabilisation in an already politically unstable country. The rebuilding of a functioning economy that can bring employment for the people and raise them out of poverty. Creating civil society and recreating the rule of law in a previously violent country. In short Haiti needs nation building.
Aid to Haiti should focus on rebuilding institutions not buildings.
Yes, because... Need to construct an effective civil society and competent government so in the future Haiti is more able to help itself.
At present 30% of the Haitian civil service are phantom employees who never turn up to work[1]. Trying to develop big business on the island would just lead to the same people in the government making the money with no trickling down of wealth.
See history of changes to this point
Aid to Haiti should focus on rebuilding institutions not buildings.
Yes, because... It is not economic institutions that are the essential ingredients for a developed democracy.
Political participation and a strong civil society are also important. The reason why countries are considered developed is if they can provide their citizens with adequate resources such as healthcare, education and a political voice. These are key in developing individuals who are healthy and free to challenge and improve their own countries. Haiti does not need to attract big businesses, which will do nothing but widen the gap between the poor citizens of the country, and the rich ex-pats who come over from America to run businesses on the island. Government institutions need to be rebuilt. The Ministry of Public Health collapsed, the Ministry of Education collapsed, the Ministry of Transportation collapsed and the Agriculture Ministry collapsed as did the presidential palace. These need to be rebuilt in order to bring some stability.
Aid to Haiti should focus on rebuilding institutions not buildings.
Yes, because... Need to develop strong local communities and initiatives. Empowering people at a local level is a vital first step
70% of Haiti is rural. Investment and aid needs to reach the rural areas instead of focusing on cities. Rural communities are generally more united and disasters like earthquakes will bring people together and unite them so the crucial next step is to pump money into local and community projects controlled by the people, not the government. If people can help each other at a local level this will eventually work its way upwards to central government. New schools need to be built to accommodate not only those who lost their schools in the earthquake but also to provide somewhere for the 40% of children who did not attend school before the earthquake to learn. Good teachers need to be attracted from across the Caribbean and North America to help set up these schools and to develop them into effective centres for education and opportunity for a new generation.
Rebuilding the building that were destroyed can also empower people and local communities. If the buildings are being donated then the people are being given something of worth, they can then use this to get loans and other capital to set up small businesses, improve health and eductation. Microfinance has proven to be very sucessful at improving the quality of life of people. Aid rebuilding buildings can provide this microfinance at the same time.
Vote on this point: Need to develop strong local communities and initiatives. Empowering people at a local level is a vital first step
See history of changes to this point
Aid to Haiti should focus on rebuilding institutions not buildings.
Yes, because... Haiti was already broken
piecing it back together or patching it up will leave it even more vulnerable when the next disaster strikes. A new Haiti needs to be built and this does not start with government and big business and industry but with the Haitian people. Rebuilding old government offices may provide some symbolic incentive – a new building and a new way of doing things. There is no point building a new shell and replacing the same old faulty contents.
Aid to Haiti should focus on rebuilding institutions not buildings.
No, because... Need to rebuild buildings in order to help to raise capital and the economy
Raising capital to rebuild will almost certainly come mostly from outside of Haiti. If Haiti is dependent on internal sources then with so much destruction all is lost. In the short term funding for the economy, the creation of business as well as for rebuilding will have to come from outside of Haiti. This would be part of rebuilding insitutions rather than buildings. Rebuilding the economy is essential but rebuilding buildings may not be the best way to do it.
Without some sort of foreign investment in the business or industrial sectors Haiti will not have the money it needs to rejuvenate and renew itself. The country cannot continue to be dependent on aid. In order for education and healthcare to improve and be more widely available the government needs to make money to provide them. Haiti cannot develop an education and welfare system solely on aid payments.
Point 1. Need to construct an effective civil society and competent government so in the future Haiti is more able to help itself.
At present 30% of the Haitian civil service are phantom employees who never turn up to work (http://www.newsweek.com/id/232080). Trying to develop big business on the island would just lead to the same people in the government making the money with no trickling down of wealth.
Point 2. It is not economic institutions that are the essential ingredients for a developed democracy.
Political participation and a strong civil society are also important. The reason why countries are considered developed is if they can provide their citizens with adequate resources such as healthcare, education and a political voice. These are key in developing individuals who are healthy and free to challenge and improve their own countries. Haiti does not need to attract big businesses, which will do nothing but widen the gap between the poor citizens of the country, and the rich ex-pats who come over from America to run businesses on the island. Government institutions need to be rebuilt. The Ministry of Public Health collapsed, the Ministry of Education collapsed, the Ministry of Transportation collapsed and the Agriculture Ministry collapsed as did the presidential palace. These need to be rebuilt in order to bring some stability.
Point 3. Need to develop strong local communities and initiatives. Empowering people at a local level is a vital first step
70% of Haiti is rural. Investment and aid needs to reach the rural areas instead of focusing on cities. Rural communities are generally more united and disasters like earthquakes will bring people together and unite them so the crucial next step is to pump money into local and community projects controlled by the people, not the government. If people can help each other at a local level this will eventually work its way upwards to central government. New schools need to be built to accommodate not only those who lost their schools in the earthquake but also to provide somewhere for the 40% of children who did not attend school before the earthquake to learn. Good teachers need to be attracted from across the Caribbean and North America to help set up these schools and to develop them into effective centres for education and opportunity for a new generation.
Rebuilding the building that were destroyed can also empower people and local communities. If the buildings are being donated then the people are being given something of worth, they can then use this to get loans and other capital to set up small businesses, improve health and eductation. Microfinance has proven to be very sucessful at improving the quality of life of people. Aid rebuilding buildings can provide this microfinance at the same time.
Point 4. Haiti was already broken
piecing it back together or patching it up will leave it even more vulnerable when the next disaster strikes. A new Haiti needs to be built and this does not start with government and big business and industry but with the Haitian people. Rebuilding old government offices may provide some symbolic incentive – a new building and a new way of doing things. There is no point building a new shell and replacing the same old faulty contents.
Point 1. Need to rebuild buildings in order to help to raise capital and the economy
Without some sort of foreign investment in the business or industrial sectors Haiti will not have the money it needs to rejuvenate and renew itself. The country cannot continue to be dependent on aid. In order for education and healthcare to improve and be more widely available the government needs to make money to provide them. Haiti cannot develop an education and welfare system solely on aid payments.
Raising capital to rebuild will almost certainly come mostly from outside of Haiti. If Haiti is dependent on internal sources then with so much destruction all is lost. In the short term funding for the economy, the creation of business as well as for rebuilding will have to come from outside of Haiti. This would be part of rebuilding insitutions rather than buildings. Rebuilding the economy is essential but rebuilding buildings may not be the best way to do it.