Modified:
17 Jan 2010
by Booji

Vote totals:

Yes:

0%

No:

0%

Neutral:

0%

 
Subscribe to This Debate
You are not currently subscribed to this debate.


Subscribe to Newsletter
Tell a Friend
(Use commas to separate)
Bookmark and Share


DEBATE: SNOW IS GOOD FOR OUR ECONOMY

A lot has been in the news regarding the effect the snow and cold weather has had on our economy, and most agree that the snow has been disastrous for a recession struck financial structure. However, can we find the positive aspects that the snow has had on our economy?





SNOW IS GOOD FOR OUR ECONOMY


Increase in snow related sales.


Many traders have taken advantage of an increase in novelty snow items which often get left unsold in the UK. Halfords reported increases in the sales of snow chains which are chains attached to vehicle wheels to help cars gain grip in the cold conditions. They also reported an increase in sales of de-icer and a 22% increase in sleeping bags[1]! With consumers spending their money instead of saving it, the snow has helped by building our economy that one small step up.
  1. ^ http://www.yorkpress.co.uk/news/4835299.Deluge_of_snow_hits_North_Yorkshire_traders/

People only have a limited amount of money in their pockets. The more they spend their money on products such as sleeping bags, they the less they will spend in other areas.


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Yes
Strongly Yes
Mostly Yes
Partially Yes
Neutral
Partially No
Mostly No
Strongly No
Absolutely No

SNOW IS GOOD FOR OUR ECONOMY


Trade will be busier than normal in the following days


Many things that snow stops people from doing will be reconvened for when the snow stops. Take for example doing the weekly grocery shop. For a few days, people may stave off and use their left over food instead of buying more. However, they will reschedule their shopping trip for when the snow stops. In the preceding days after snow therefore, shops will be busier. This will also be when staff arrive back from work. Given that staff this year have been made to take snow days as holiday or unpaid leave, the shops are actually making a profit out of the snow. They are getting a higher level of productivity after the days of snow from their workers and therefore making more profit than they would have with no snow.

The proposed argument is that people will not shop during a week of snow, but will shop twice as much the following week.

The only reason that the economy is more active after a snow day is because it is less active during a snow day. Essentially, the two cancel each other out.

The fallacy is that snow does not increase the demand for products such as food. A person will most likely buy the same amount of food as they always do snow or shine.


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Yes
Strongly Yes
Mostly Yes
Partially Yes
Neutral
Partially No
Mostly No
Strongly No
Absolutely No

SNOW IS GOOD FOR OUR ECONOMY


Salt miners are having a whale of a time!


Any business that operates in the salt mining industry is laughing when the snow comes falling down. The council is saying that these miners are not producing enough salt for them to purchase! In addition, these salt mines are in the midlands or the north, places like Chester and Teeside, so the salt has to be transported around the country and mainly to the city. This means the additional hiring of lorry drivers. Given that unemployment rates are higher in the midlands/north, the additional hiring of lorry drivers in these areas can only have a more positive affect on our economy.

Conversely, the warm weather economy (such as the sale of air conditioners and pools) aren't having as much of a "whale of a time" and will lose jobs during the winter.

If there were no snow, we wouldn't need to employ salt miners or lorry drivers. We would have more money in our pockets and we could allocate it towards different services.

With that same logic, earthquakes would be good for our economy because house builders will make more money.


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Yes
Strongly Yes
Mostly Yes
Partially Yes
Neutral
Partially No
Mostly No
Strongly No
Absolutely No

SNOW IS GOOD FOR OUR ECONOMY


Fun purchases become a regular occurrence


Around the time of a big freeze full of snow, certain sales increase. One of the main sales is leisure items. The sale of sledges is one of them! These items would normally go unsold, but the snow promulgates their purchase and this helps our economy. Especially when you consider that given the icy conditions and the harsh way children play, that sledge will either break and so need to be purchased again for the next snow season or whilst in storage for the next snow season it will rust. And once children have spent one snow day with a sledge, they will expect nothing less every snow day. Therefore, this one purchase due to the snow could in fact lead to an annual sale. And this can be nothing but good for the economy.

People only have a limited amount of money in their pockets. The more they spend their money on snow-related fun products, they the less they will spend in other areas.


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Yes
Strongly Yes
Mostly Yes
Partially Yes
Neutral
Partially No
Mostly No
Strongly No
Absolutely No

SNOW IS GOOD FOR OUR ECONOMY


10% of staff do not make it to work when it snows


When snow falls, it causes travel disruptions. January 2009 was much like January 2010 with the city coming to almost a standstill. Trains were cancelled and delayed, buses stopped travelling on their routes because it was too dangerous and people were stuck in hours of traffic. This can do one of two things to a company. It can either cause them to pay staff when they are not working, as if they arrive late permanent members of staff will get paid for the whole day, or the staff will take the day off resulting in a loss of productivity. Either way, businesses lose out on money. This is in no way good for a recession bound economy trying to recover it once high GDP (gross domestic product= the total value of all good and services produced in that country).



SNOW IS GOOD FOR OUR ECONOMY


Lunch providers will be hit.


But this would be levelled out by the fact that children who have had the day off school, instead of having homemade packed lunch from their parents, they will probably be out with their friends and they will purchase the lunch items. Normally they would not be allowed outside the school gates to make such purchases, but when they have the opportunity they will relish it. Parents will leave their children money in order to make such purchases.

With 10% of employees taking a snow day, businesses who make their profit by selling lunch to workers will be struck hard. From Tesco’s to the office sandwich man, the sale of lunch items could potentially go down 10%. Stores and cafes would be hit the worse as the people who did actually make it into work would then be reluctant to leave to get lunch and instead opt for eating a homemade sandwich. Given that lunch time in the city is big business (you only need to look at the amount of Starbuck and Café Nero’s to know this) the economy is adversely affected when sales in this department fall.


What do you think?  Vote on this point below.
Absolutely Yes
Strongly Yes
Mostly Yes
Partially Yes
Neutral
Partially No
Mostly No
Strongly No
Absolutely No

SNOW IS GOOD FOR OUR ECONOMY


Snow is a hazard


Snow entails a large burden on the economy. Every winter requires the shoveling of snow, the consumption of more fuel in automobiles, the consumption of more energy to keep houses warm, and specific attire.

Granted, all of that creates jobs, but if it were to never snow, we would all have more money in our pockets, and we could allocate it to different jobs such as feeding the hungry and rebuilding dilapidated neighborhoods.




Vote on the overall debate: Snow is good for our economy

What do you think?  Vote on this debate below.
Absolutely Yes
Strongly Yes
Mostly Yes
Partially Yes
Neutral
Partially No
Mostly No
Strongly No
Absolutely No
1. Increase in snow related sales.
# 1

Many traders have taken advantage of an increase in novelty snow items which often get left unsold in the UK. Halfords reported increases in the sales of snow chains which are chains attached to vehicle wheels to help cars gain grip in the cold conditions. They also reported an increase in sales of de-icer and a 22% increase in sleeping bags[1]! With consumers spending their money instead of saving it, the snow has helped by building our economy that one small step up.
  1. ^ http://www.yorkpress.co.uk/news/4835299.Deluge_of_snow_hits_North_Yorkshire_traders/

LLBlynch

|

16:50, 15 January 10

|

Karma Score: 2699


# 2

People only have a limited amount of money in their pockets. The more they spend their money on products such as sleeping bags, they the less they will spend in other areas.

Juggernaut

|

15:18, 17 January 10

|

Karma Score: 15



2. Trade will be busier than normal in the following days
# 1

Many things that snow stops people from doing will be reconvened for when the snow stops. Take for example doing the weekly grocery shop. For a few days, people may stave off and use their left over food instead of buying more. However, they will reschedule their shopping trip for when the snow stops. In the preceding days after snow therefore, shops will be busier. This will also be when staff arrive back from work. Given that staff this year have been made to take snow days as holiday or unpaid leave, the shops are actually making a profit out of the snow. They are getting a higher level of productivity after the days of snow from their workers and therefore making more profit than they would have with no snow.

LLBlynch

|

17:19, 15 January 10

|

Karma Score: 2699


# 2

The proposed argument is that people will not shop during a week of snow, but will shop twice as much the following week.

The only reason that the economy is more active after a snow day is because it is less active during a snow day. Essentially, the two cancel each other out.

The fallacy is that snow does not increase the demand for products such as food. A person will most likely buy the same amount of food as they always do snow or shine.

Juggernaut

|

15:09, 17 January 10

|

Karma Score: 15



3. Salt miners are having a whale of a time!
# 1

Any business that operates in the salt mining industry is laughing when the snow comes falling down. The council is saying that these miners are not producing enough salt for them to purchase! In addition, these salt mines are in the midlands or the north, places like Chester and Teeside, so the salt has to be transported around the country and mainly to the city. This means the additional hiring of lorry drivers. Given that unemployment rates are higher in the midlands/north, the additional hiring of lorry drivers in these areas can only have a more positive affect on our economy.

LLBlynch

|

17:31, 15 January 10

|

Karma Score: 2699


# 2

Conversely, the warm weather economy (such as the sale of air conditioners and pools) aren't having as much of a "whale of a time" and will lose jobs during the winter.

If there were no snow, we wouldn't need to employ salt miners or lorry drivers. We would have more money in our pockets and we could allocate it towards different services.

With that same logic, earthquakes would be good for our economy because house builders will make more money.

Juggernaut

|

15:15, 17 January 10

|

Karma Score: 15



4. Fun purchases become a regular occurrence
# 1

Around the time of a big freeze full of snow, certain sales increase. One of the main sales is leisure items. The sale of sledges is one of them! These items would normally go unsold, but the snow promulgates their purchase and this helps our economy. Especially when you consider that given the icy conditions and the harsh way children play, that sledge will either break and so need to be purchased again for the next snow season or whilst in storage for the next snow season it will rust. And once children have spent one snow day with a sledge, they will expect nothing less every snow day. Therefore, this one purchase due to the snow could in fact lead to an annual sale. And this can be nothing but good for the economy.

LLBlynch

|

17:38, 15 January 10

|

Karma Score: 2699


# 2

People only have a limited amount of money in their pockets. The more they spend their money on snow-related fun products, they the less they will spend in other areas.

Juggernaut

|

15:17, 17 January 10

|

Karma Score: 15



1. 10% of staff do not make it to work when it snows
# 1

When snow falls, it causes travel disruptions. January 2009 was much like January 2010 with the city coming to almost a standstill. Trains were cancelled and delayed, buses stopped travelling on their routes because it was too dangerous and people were stuck in hours of traffic. This can do one of two things to a company. It can either cause them to pay staff when they are not working, as if they arrive late permanent members of staff will get paid for the whole day, or the staff will take the day off resulting in a loss of productivity. Either way, businesses lose out on money. This is in no way good for a recession bound economy trying to recover it once high GDP (gross domestic product= the total value of all good and services produced in that country).

LLBlynch

|

17:02, 15 January 10

|

Karma Score: 2699



2. Lunch providers will be hit.
# 1

With 10% of employees taking a snow day, businesses who make their profit by selling lunch to workers will be struck hard. From Tesco’s to the office sandwich man, the sale of lunch items could potentially go down 10%. Stores and cafes would be hit the worse as the people who did actually make it into work would then be reluctant to leave to get lunch and instead opt for eating a homemade sandwich. Given that lunch time in the city is big business (you only need to look at the amount of Starbuck and Café Nero’s to know this) the economy is adversely affected when sales in this department fall.

LLBlynch

|

17:08, 15 January 10

|

Karma Score: 2699


# 2

But this would be levelled out by the fact that children who have had the day off school, instead of having homemade packed lunch from their parents, they will probably be out with their friends and they will purchase the lunch items. Normally they would not be allowed outside the school gates to make such purchases, but when they have the opportunity they will relish it. Parents will leave their children money in order to make such purchases.

LLBlynch

|

17:25, 15 January 10

|

Karma Score: 2699



3. Snow is a hazard
# 1

Snow entails a large burden on the economy. Every winter requires the shoveling of snow, the consumption of more fuel in automobiles, the consumption of more energy to keep houses warm, and specific attire.

Granted, all of that creates jobs, but if it were to never snow, we would all have more money in our pockets, and we could allocate it to different jobs such as feeding the hungry and rebuilding dilapidated neighborhoods.

Juggernaut

|

14:59, 17 January 10

|

Karma Score: 15



Loading...